Wednesday, 18 March 2009

The Current State of My Hobby

Please note that this post is entitled "The Current State of MY Hobby", but maybe my current state is similar to other collectors out there. Perhaps some of these thoughts might also apply to "The Current State of THE Hobby".

The journey to get back in collecting has been fun and nostalgic as I open box after box of cards that haven't seen the light of day in 15-20 years. It is taking longer than expected now that I've gotten sidetracked by the 2009 Topps cards that were released last month. After buying a "hobby box" and various other loose packs, I've finally completed the 2009 Series One and additionally have small piles of insert cards, "game-used" cards, parallel cards, and miscellaneous duplicates to look at, some better than others. But I have a nagging suspicion that I have been going about collecting the "new" stuff the wrong way.

I don't have buyer's remorse, but all of this action in the past month has led me to a realization. It is far, far cheaper just to go to eBay and buy a set of cards than trying to collect a set by buying packs. This may seem obvious to most of you, but the difference between the two methods is astonishing. I may have spent $120-$140 in small increments over the past 6 weeks just to complete half (or a third) of the 2009 Topps set, whereas that same set of cards, minus the duplicates and inserts can be had for less than $20 on eBay, shipping included. And I am fairly certain that by the year end I would be able to buy the entire set of Series 1 and 2 even cheaper.

So what do you miss by taking the quick and dirty route to set-building? Well, you certainly miss the thrill of opening a pack of cards, and especially the excitement that your pack might contain (it doesn't) some amazing insert card that MIGHT be valuable or at least entertaining to look at. At least, in theory, that seems like a lot to give up, since that was originally the fun of baseball card collecting. In reality it is completely insane to attempt to complete any insert set simply by buying packs. I have even spent the last few weeks attempting to trade for the last of the 2009 Turkey Red Set (rather, HALF of the Turkey Red Set), which has been interesting, but I am still missing 9 cards, or almost 20%. I am even further from completing any of the other insert sets. It used to feel like cheating to buy a complete set at a card show or on eBay. I was missing out on half the fun of card collecting, right?

My experience this month has erased that vague feeling of guilt. A quick perusal of eBay again reveals that these elusive inserts can be bought quickly and in total for less than I have spent so far. What is so insane about not wanting to spend $300+ dollars for a set of baseball cards every year? The joy of collecting for me is to look at the cards, not to tally their total net value in some fanciful Beckett-induced fantasy. Trading is fun, collecting is fun, but SPENDING a lot of money is not always necessary for fun. For the same $300 I could buy the entire 2009 set plus an entire set of cards from the 1970's for instance. Stretching the collecting dollar is totally within the spirit of the hobby in my opinion. I think from now on I am going to be more judicious about where I spend the baseball card dollar. The farther I can stretch it, the better, no?

I'm not going to state that Topps has made card collecting too complicated. If the demand is there, than by all means, I hope Topps can supply it and be profitable and the more the better. If the general public wants a bunch of inserts and chase cards to track down and Topps can sell more cards by providing it, then let me step out of the way and let it roll.


There is one area of collecting that I will step up and call madness. I only have had to look at three of these atrocities to know a stupid idea when I see it. Below are three "game-used artifact" cards, or "relics" as they are distastefully called. Would I like a game-used jersey in my collection? Perhaps yes, if it was George Brett's #5 that he wore during one of his campaigns. Probably no if it was a player I had no strong connection with at all. Would I want a tiny piece of George Brett's jersey crammed into a poorly made card with his picture slapped on it? Not at all. Is there really any meaning to be found in a 1" square piece of fabric that looks like every other 1" piece of fabric I've ever seen? How about a bat? Again, not a bad souvenir IF I could actually hold the bat and imagine it being used to strike the decisive blow in a big game at the hands of one my heroes. How about a small sliver of wood that may or may not have at one time been a bat, but looks identical to a sliver of wood that at one time might have been the end of a doorstop in some derelict office complex or housing project? Umm, no thanks.

There may be some perceived value in these cards currently, but there will someday be a glut of relic cards so vast and so worthless that it will make the overproduction issues of the 1980's and 1990's seem trivial. At least today, twenty years later, there is still some demand for the cards of that era. Collectors share a common connection with these cards because they are so familiar and easy to obtain. The blogosphere has come alive the past year or two with rhapsodic musings about baseball players and teams of that bygone era simply because there are so many other collectors out there that can appreciate it. They also have had the same thoughts and revels about the same cards and players I had many years ago and can relate to it well. After reading an exceptional post on a blog I actually experience a desire to go look at that card the writer was referencing.

How can there be any common connection with a card that is "1/1", or "34/51" or other nonsense? In the future is there going to a blogpost about some rare relic card of a journeyman shortstop that will mean anything if no one else has actually seen or held that card before? If my experience with cards is at all common, than the answer will be "NO".

I can fully imagine an eBay auction in 20 years for "800 GU Jersey/Bat Cards - NICE! with a Buy It Now option of $9.99 FREE SHIPPING!" that will end without a sale.

This isn't even addressing the depressing thought that actual pieces of history are being destroyed by band saw and fabric shear. Isn't there any better use for a pile of authentic game-worn jerseys and game-used bats than putting them in a proverbial paper-shredder? How about the novel idea of selling the ACTUAL jersey and/or bat? How about random redemption cards that could used to obtain the actual item? Who came up with the crazy idea that the best use of a Major League Baseball player's game bat is the take it the wood shop and hack it into tiny pieces?

I think this latest process takes the collector beyond simple fandom and into a semi-religious realm of literal hero-worship. The cards are even called "relics" just like the tiny slivers of bone and hair from the saints contained in the reliquaries of every Medieval cathedral . This level of collecting makes me think more of "creepy" than "cool". Am I alone here?

I will be giving away all three cards here, starting with the one and only contributor to my post on the Rickey Henderson card. So, if MMayes of the "1972 Topps Baseball" blog cares to email me, the card of his choice is his. Email me a toppsbaseball at If none of those cards interests you, email me anyway and we can work out another prize. Thanks!

One last comment before I go. As I actually look at these cards I am amazed at the craftmanship, or lack thereof, in these cards. Some have loose threads, all have irregular cut mattes surrounding the patch which seems to indicate that it was cut by hand with an exacto knife instead of an automated press. Amazing!


  1. Just discovered this blog and love it. I'm a 40-something who returned to collecting about two years ago, going back through my old cards (mostly late 60s to mid-80s) and also buying new ones.

    The pack price of new cards was what got me to just buy entire sets online. It's not my preferred method - opening a pack and having the excitement of going through it is lost.

    But with 12 cards in a pack selling for $1.99 putting together a set is prohibitively expensive. So getting say, Topps 2009 Series 1, online for $30 is a comparative steal.

    Look forward to reading all the prior posts.

  2. Oh, and ditto to what you said about the game-used cards. To me there's almost a creepy 'Shroud of Turin' vibe to them that takes fandom too far.

    I'm a traditionalist who just wants the standard set of cards - Topps, what I grew up with - each year.

  3. Nice little article, and I couldn't agree more yet the incredibly sad fact is Topps series 1 & 2 are the cheapest sets to collect!

    This year Topps also has a nice variety of cards you'll never see, but you could see them, right?

    Shoot me an email at ( info @ ) with what you're missing out of the Turkey Red Set..

    I think i have more dupes than cards.

    By the way, the topps autographs are about 100x better than Upper Decks, so you can at least be glad about that, right?

  4. As some one that was born in 1970 I have seen my share of cards back in the 70's ,, but as i get older and wish i had all the ones i put in the spokes and the ones my mom tossed .
    Starting to get back into collecting again with a mission to collect a set from each year form when i was born to hopefully till the year i die (hopefully not for a long time) buying the new sets by packs is some thing i like to do but like you said the insert sets could be a pain and a wast of card board in my eyes and have no use for the piece of history stuff JER/BAT/AUTO But i must say i love your idea of putting redemption cards in the packs for the whole item BAT,BALL,JERRSY Heck i would by more packs that way !!!!

  5. I'm coming across this blog only due to the fact it's been inactive for 5 months.

    A lot of what you said in this entry how many people feel - including myself.

    I won't reiterate what others stated, but this was a great read and it would be great to hear where you ended up in your collection.

  6. Are you still trading cards? I'm getting back into collecting and would like to complete some "sets." email me at davisholden @ gmailcom

  7. Really good post,
    I have a CJ Wilson Auto from this collection.
    I'm new to collecting but i believe Allen & Ginter's jersey cards are terrible.

    As for GU shirts, I think they should be kept and donated to local charities for charity auctions & raffles.

  8. Your thoughts on the jersey cards and sliced bat cards echo the thinking of thousands of card collectors. This does nothing but drive up the price of cards. It also results in regular issues that are paper thin and easily damaged. This is what sunk Upper Deck. I quit buying them when I started getting cards dinged and damaged right out of the packs, pack fresh. I liked their Yankees history inserts a lot but I refrained from chasing them because of the thin card stock. Now you can pick tnem up at most card shows for 50 cents already in a plastic holder. I'm a set builder so I'm always looking to trade baseball -- glad to get want lists at I also need a few 97 Playoff Absolute football.

  9. I am big fan of card collector do you know some one who help me for that.
    Scratch Card printing
    plastic cards
    membership card printing